Susan Spess Shay

Still playing make believe.

Top Turkeyday Treats

1 Comment

There’s one in every family. You know the one I mean. The dish that has to be on every holiday table. It’s so good, there’s rarely any left at the end of the day, no matter how much you make.

When my kids were growing up, I thought it would be a fruit salad my husband’s stepmother made–Mattie’s Fruit Salad. It was good, but not quite as good (to my boys, anyway) as the salad my mom had been making forever–Strawberry Salad. I’m never sure if it’s a salad or a dessert, so I just put it on the table and we eat it through the entire meal.

Cheryl Allen put the salad in our church cookbook.

  My cookbook is well worn! LOL.

Here it is:


1 large package strawberry Jello
2 C. boiling water
1 lb. strawberries (one box, frozen)
1 small flat can crushed pineapple.

Mix all and set. (I use frozen strawberries and add them instead of the cold water to the Jello.)
Before serving, add sour cream over top of Jello mixture.

Image via Wikipedia

My mother put half the Jello mixture in the fridge to set, put the sour cream on it, then topped with the other half so there was a stripe of sour cream in the middle. I found Cheryl’s way to be much easier unless doubling the recipe. (I hate having unset Jello in my way, on the counter, waiting for the first half to jell.)

And since it’s Thanksgiving, and I’m thankful to have had her in my life, I’m going to share Mattie’s Fruit Salad.

1 box frozen strawberries
one can fruit cocktail, drained
1 apple, peeled and chopped, and/or 1 banana sliced and/or a bunch of seedless grapes
1/2 pint container of sour cream
Defrost strawberries and drain juice. Mix strawberry juice with sour cream and pour over thawed strawberries, fruit cocktail and other fruit and mix until all the fruit is coated well.

These recipes are oh, so good!
Now you have two great salad recipes that just might do as a dessert. 🙂 Help yourself!

What’s the must-have dish for your table?

Author: Susan Shay

For as long as I can remember, I've loved two things--reading and people--and that led me to become a writer. Many of my stories are set in Small Town Worlds. I'm a wife, mother, sibling and an aunt. I have a deep faith in God, and an exciting life in Christ. Maybe I shouldn't be (after all, he's God!) but I'm constantly amazed at the things He's up to. :)

One thought on “Top Turkeyday Treats

  1. Pingback: Fun Fruit Salad | Fresh Salads

I'm so glad you dropped by my Small Town World! Hope you'll leave a comment. I really enjoy hearing from you!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s